McNasty League
🏈2026 Punishments list has been agreed onClick here to view punishments →
← All NFL Teams
AFC South

Indianapolis Colts

Every IND player selected in McNasty League draft history, organized by season.

77
Total draft picks
34
Unique players
12
Draft seasons represented
2015–2026
Draft history span
Top Drafter

Tyler

Manager with the most IND selections in league draft history.
8picks6 unique players

2026 Draft

5 IND picks
View full draft →
Overall#5
Jonathan TaylorRB · Round 1, Pick 5
Drafted byMichael
Overall#80
Alec PierceWR · Round 7, Pick 8
Drafted bySam
Overall#88
Tyler WarrenTE · Round 8, Pick 9
Drafted byAndy
Overall#105
Josh DownsWR · Round 9, Pick 9
Drafted byAndy
Overall#167
Keenan AllenWR · Round 14, Pick 2
Drafted byJustin

2025 Draft

5 IND picks
View full draft →
Overall#14
Jonathan TaylorRB · Round 2, Pick 11
Drafted bySam
Overall#95
Michael PittmanWR · Round 8, Pick 2
Drafted byJustin
Overall#100
Tyler WarrenTE · Round 9, Pick 4
Drafted byButters
Overall#116
Josh DownsWR · Round 10, Pick 5
Drafted byAndy
Overall#183
Adonai MitchellWR · Round 16, Pick 10
Drafted byHenry

2024 Draft

5 IND picks
View full draft →
Overall#9
Jonathan TaylorRB · Round 1, Pick 9
Drafted byJustin
Overall#41
Michael PittmanWR · Round 4, Pick 8
Drafted byMichael
Overall#93
Anthony RichardsonQB · Round 8, Pick 4
Drafted byAndy
Overall#131
Adonai MitchellWR · Round 11, Pick 11
Drafted byKristian
Overall#143
Josh DownsWR · Round 12, Pick 2
Drafted bySawm

2023 Draft

4 IND picks
View full draft →
Overall#28
Jonathan TaylorRB · Round 3, Pick 4
Drafted bySam
Overall#83
Michael PittmanWR · Round 7, Pick 11
Drafted byAndy
Overall#130
Zack MossRB · Round 11, Pick 10
Drafted byTyler
Overall#191
Matt GayK · Round 16, Pick 2
Drafted bySawm

2022 Draft

7 IND picks
View full draft →
Overall#1
Jonathan TaylorRB · Round 1, Pick 1
Drafted bySawm
Overall#31
Michael PittmanWR · Round 3, Pick 7
Drafted byJustin
Overall#118
Nyheim HinesRB · Round 10, Pick 3
Drafted byAndy
Overall#176
Indianapolis ColtsDEF · Round 15, Pick 8
Drafted byButters
Overall#178
Rodrigo BlankenshipK · Round 15, Pick 10
Drafted byKristian
Overall#188
Alec PierceWR · Round 16, Pick 5
Drafted byKian
Overall#191
Parris CampbellWR · Round 16, Pick 2
Drafted byHenry

2021 Draft

7 IND picks
View full draft →
Overall#9
Jonathan TaylorRB · Round 1, Pick 9
Drafted byJustin
Overall#106
Michael PittmanWR · Round 9, Pick 10
Drafted byButters
Overall#127
T.Y. HiltonWR · Round 11, Pick 7
Drafted byBDo
Overall#128
Nyheim HinesRB · Round 11, Pick 8
Drafted byKristian
Overall#159
Marlon MackRB · Round 14, Pick 10
Drafted byButters
Overall#180
Rodrigo BlankenshipK · Round 15, Pick 12
Drafted byKris
Overall#198
Parris CampbellWR · Round 17, Pick 6
Drafted byKian

2020 Draft

8 IND picks
View full draft →
Overall#35
Jonathan TaylorRB · Round 3, Pick 11
Drafted byKian
Overall#58
T.Y. HiltonWR · Round 5, Pick 10
Drafted byMichael
Overall#74
Marlon MackRB · Round 7, Pick 2
Drafted byTyler
Overall#151
Michael Pittman Jr.WR · Round 13, Pick 7
Drafted byButters
Overall#155
Parris CampbellWR · Round 13, Pick 11
Drafted byKian
Overall#178
Philip RiversQB · Round 15, Pick 10
Drafted byMichael
Overall#181
Nyheim HinesRB · Round 16, Pick 12
Drafted byJustin
Overall#186
Jack DoyleTE · Round 16, Pick 7
Drafted byButters

2019 Draft

6 IND picks
View full draft →
Overall#34
Marlon MackRB · Round 3, Pick 10
Drafted byKristian
Overall#42
T.Y. HiltonWR · Round 4, Pick 7
Drafted byHenry
Overall#85
Eric EbronTE · Round 8, Pick 12
Drafted byKris
Overall#159
D'Onta ForemanRB · Round 14, Pick 10
Drafted byKristian
Overall#180
Devin FunchessWR · Round 15, Pick 12
Drafted byKris
Overall#192
Nyheim HinesRB · Round 16, Pick 1
Drafted byBDo

2018 Draft

6 IND picks
View full draft →
Overall#21
T.Y. HiltonWR · Round 2, Pick 4
Drafted byNick
Overall#61
Marlon MackRB · Round 6, Pick 12
Drafted byBDo
Overall#90
Andrew LuckQB · Round 8, Pick 7
Drafted byTyler
Overall#103
Jordan WilkinsRB · Round 9, Pick 7
Drafted byTyler
Overall#135
Jack DoyleTE · Round 12, Pick 10
Drafted byKevin
Overall#186
Ryan GrantWR · Round 16, Pick 7
Drafted byTyler

2017 Draft

8 IND picks
View full draft →
Overall#19
T.Y. HiltonWR · Round 2, Pick 6
Drafted byKevin
Overall#73
Donte MoncriefWR · Round 7, Pick 1
Drafted byTyler
Overall#78
Frank GoreRB · Round 7, Pick 6
Drafted byKevin
Overall#92
Andrew LuckQB · Round 8, Pick 5
Drafted byChris
Overall#158
Marlon MackRB · Round 14, Pick 11
Drafted byKian
Overall#174
Robert TurbinRB · Round 15, Pick 6
Drafted byKevin
Overall#177
Jack DoyleTE · Round 15, Pick 9
Drafted byBDo
Overall#184
Adam VinatieriK · Round 16, Pick 9
Drafted byBDo

2016 Draft

7 IND picks
View full draft →
Overall#39
T.Y. HiltonWR · Round 4, Pick 10
Drafted byKris
Overall#57
Donte MoncriefWR · Round 5, Pick 9
Drafted byTyler
Overall#67
Andrew LuckQB · Round 6, Pick 6
Drafted byTaylor
Overall#82
Frank GoreRB · Round 7, Pick 10
Drafted byKris
Overall#118
Phillip Dorsett IIWR · Round 10, Pick 3
Drafted byKian
Overall#176
Dwayne AllenTE · Round 15, Pick 8
Drafted byHenry
Overall#183
Adam VinatieriK · Round 16, Pick 10
Drafted byKris

2015 Draft

9 IND picks
View full draft →
Overall#23
Andrew LuckQB · Round 2, Pick 11
Drafted byTyler
Overall#25
T.Y. HiltonWR · Round 3, Pick 1
Drafted byMichael
Overall#29
Frank GoreRB · Round 3, Pick 5
Drafted byJake
Overall#38
Andre JohnsonWR · Round 4, Pick 2
Drafted byTianna
Overall#125
Dwayne AllenTE · Round 11, Pick 5
Drafted byJake
Overall#152
Coby FleenerTE · Round 13, Pick 8
Drafted byKevin
Overall#154
Adam VinatieriK · Round 13, Pick 10
Drafted byChris
Overall#163
Phillip DorsettWR · Round 14, Pick 7
Drafted byLuis
Overall#171
Donte MoncriefWR · Round 15, Pick 3
Drafted bySam